Forced Bankruptcy by Creditors: When Creditors Pull the Trigger

What is Involuntary Bankruptcy?

‍

Involuntary bankruptcy is a legal process where forced bankruptcy by creditors is established onto the debtor through the courts, even if the debtor has not filed voluntarily. This allows creditors to take legal action to recover debts when a debtor is unable or unwilling to pay.

‍

The main parties involved in involuntary bankruptcy are the creditors (petitioners) and the debtor (the target of the involuntary petition). To be eligible to file an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor, creditors must meet certain criteria set out in the Bankruptcy Code. 

‍

For creditors, the legal requirements to file an involuntary bankruptcy petition include:

‍

• The debtor must generally owe at least $16,750 to the petitioning creditor(s). This minimum debt threshold applies for a single petitioning creditor.

‍

• If there are multiple petitioning creditors, the debtor must owe in aggregate at least $16,750 in unsecured claims to the group. 

‍

• The petitioning creditor(s) must hold claims that are not contingent as to liability or subject to a bona fide dispute.

‍

• There must be at least 3 petitioning creditors to file an involuntary chapter 7 or 11 bankruptcy case against the debtor. If there are fewer than 12 total creditors, 1 petitioning creditor may be sufficient.

‍

• The petitioning creditors must file the involuntary petition in good faith.

‍

By meeting these requirements, creditors can request a court order for bankruptcy relief against a debtor who has not filed voluntarily. However, there are restrictions and creditors may face consequences if the petition is dismissed.

‍

Eligibility Requirements for Creditors

‍

In order for creditors to successfully file an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor, they must meet certain eligibility criteria set by the bankruptcy code. The most important requirements relate to the minimum number of petitioning creditors, the types of debts that can be claimed, and thresholds for single creditor petitions.

‍

Minimum Number of Petitioning Creditors

‍

To file an involuntary case, there must be 3 or more creditors included in the petition. Having multiple creditors join together strengthens the petition and demonstrates a general inability or unwillingness of the debtor to pay their debts. However, there are exceptions that allow a single creditor to file if they meet certain debt amount thresholds.

‍

Qualifying Debt Types

‍

The debts claimed by petitioning creditors must be unsecured claims that are not contingent as to liability or subject to a bona fide dispute. This means the debts must be fixed, liquidated amounts that the debtor is responsible for paying, such as credit card balances, personal loans, lines of credit, medical bills, etc. Secured debts like mortgages or car loans do not qualify.

‍

Single Creditor Eligibility

‍

If there are fewer than 12 total creditors, a single creditor can file an involuntary petition on their own. Additionally, if a single creditor is owed at least $16,750 of unsecured debt that is not contingent or subject to dispute, they can individually force the debtor into bankruptcy without needing to partner with other creditors. This threshold provides recourse for a creditor with substantial debt exposure who is not being paid by the debtor.

‍

Filing the Involuntary Bankruptcy Petition

‍

To initiate an involuntary bankruptcy case against a debtor, the petitioning creditors must file the proper documentation with the bankruptcy court in the jurisdiction where the debtor resides or has their primary place of business. This filing requires:

‍

• Official Form 105 - Known as the "involuntary petition", this form names the debtor and includes details on the debtor's location and business activities. It must be signed by all petitioning creditors or their authorized representatives.

‍

• List of creditors - The petitioning creditors must provide a full list of the debtor's creditors with names, addresses, and amounts owed. This helps establish that the petitioners meet the minimum creditor number and claim thresholds.

‍

• Filing fee - A filing fee must be paid to the bankruptcy court, though it can be waived for creditors facing financial hardship. Currently, the average fee is $335 for involuntary chapter 7 and chapter 11 cases according to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court and the district you are filing.

‍

The creditors must properly serve the involuntary petition, summons, and other documents to the debtor per federal and local rules. Usually, this involves using a process server to deliver the papers to the debtor personally or to their registered business agent.

‍

The involuntary case officially commences once the petition is filed with the bankruptcy court. The debtor then has 21 days to respond by filing an answer contesting the petition. Creditors should consult qualified bankruptcy counsel to ensure proper preparation and filing of the involuntary paperwork.

‍

Debtor's Response Options

‍

When an involuntary bankruptcy petition is filed, the debtor has several options for how to respond:

‍

Grounds for Contesting the Petition

‍

The debtor can challenge the petition and seek to have it dismissed on certain grounds. For example, the debtor may argue that the creditors did not meet the eligibility requirements, such as not having enough qualifying creditors or debt amounts. The debtor could also claim that they are generally paying debts as they become due, and are not actually insolvent. Fraud or misrepresentations by the petitioning creditors are another potential basis for dismissal.

‍

Seeking Dismissal or Conversion 

‍

Instead of contesting the petition, the debtor may request that the bankruptcy court dismiss the involuntary case altogether. This avoids a lengthy legal fight. The debtor could also ask the court to convert the involuntary case into a voluntary Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing instead. This allows the debtor to retain more control over the process.

‍

Settling Debts vs. Bankruptcy

‍

Rather than battling the involuntary bankruptcy, the debtor can attempt to negotiate debt settlement offers with the petitioning creditors. For example, the debtor may offer to set up payment plans or agree to reduced lump-sum payments to satisfy debts. The creditors may prefer these options over the risks and uncertainties of forcing the debtor into bankruptcy involuntarily. Settling debts directly can help the debtor avoid a damaging bankruptcy on their record.

‍

Limitations and Restrictions on Involuntary Bankruptcy 

‍

There are several important limitations and restrictions that apply to involuntary bankruptcy filings:

‍

Debtors Exempt from Involuntary Bankruptcy

‍

Not all debtors can be forced into bankruptcy. Certain debtors are usually exempt, including:

‍

• Farmers 
• Charitable organizations
• Non-profit entities
• Small business debtors (less than $2.7 million in debts)

‍

Bad Faith Filings and Creditor Liability

‍

Creditors can face severe penalties if they file an involuntary petition in bad faith. For example, if the filing was solely to harass the debtor or the creditors knew the debtor was not generally failing to pay debts.

‍

Consequences may include:

‍

• Paying the debtor's legal fees 
• Paying any damages caused by the filing
• Having the bankruptcy case dismissed

‍

Statute of Limitations

‍

There are time limits on how long after a debt becomes due that it can be used in an involuntary bankruptcy filing. Usually the statute of limitations is 2-6 years, depending on state law.

‍

Older debts that are past your state’s statute of limitations cannot be used to force a debtor into bankruptcy.

‍

The Involuntary Bankruptcy Process

‍

Once an involuntary bankruptcy petition is filed, the court will hold hearings to determine if the petition should be granted. The first hearing is usually within 2-3 weeks of filing where the judge reviews the petition and supporting documents. 

‍

If the judge decides the petition meets the legal requirements, the court issues an "Order for Relief" officially declaring the debtor bankrupt. This triggers the imposition of an automatic stay, preventing creditors from collecting debts outside of bankruptcy.

‍

The U.S. Trustee, an officer appointed by the Justice Department, will select an impartial case trustee to oversee the bankruptcy estate. The trustee has broad powers to liquidate assets, investigate the debtor's finances, and challenge preferential transfers.

‍

The court will issue schedules and deadlines for the bankruptcy case. The debtor has limited time to file required documents, including:

‍

• Statement of financial affairs 
• Schedules of assets and liabilities
• List of creditors

‍

Meanwhile, the trustee will arrange the first meeting of creditors, held about 20-40 days after filing. Creditors can question the debtor under oath about their finances and assets. 

‍

The automatic stay halts collections, foreclosures, repossessions, and lawsuits against the debtor outside of bankruptcy court. Creditors must obtain court permission before taking any actions against the debtor during bankruptcy.

‍

Violating the automatic stay can result in the creditor being held in contempt of court and subject to fines or damages. The stay remains in effect until discharge, dismissal, or closure of the case by the court.

‍

The trustee has powers to recover preferential transfers, fraudulent conveyances, and other assets to maximize the bankruptcy estate. These powers are strengthened in an involuntary case.

‍

Throughout the process, the debtor can still negotiate with creditors for a consensual resolution, such as a structured dismissal or conversion to voluntary Chapter 11 or 7 bankruptcy. Most involuntary cases end up settling before completion.

‍

Creditors' Rights in Involuntary Cases

‍

Once an involuntary bankruptcy case is underway, petitioning creditors have several important rights they can exercise:

‍

Participation in Creditors' Meetings

‍

The US Trustee will schedule the initial creditors' meeting, known as a 341 meeting, where creditors can question the debtor under oath. Petitioning creditors should attend and participate to gather more information about the debtor's assets and financial affairs. They can follow up with additional document requests as needed.

‍

Ability to File Claims 

‍

Petitioning creditors can file proofs of claim for the unpaid debts owed to them by the debtor. This allows them to participate in any distributions made to creditors in the case. The timing and process for filing claims will depend on whether the case ends up in Chapter 7 or 11.

‍

Potential Recoveries

‍

If assets are liquidated or proceeds obtained from legal actions, petitioning creditors may receive a distribution on their claims. Recoveries can also come from successful objections to the debtor's discharge. In Chapter 11 cases, creditors may receive payments under a reorganization plan. 

‍

However, involuntary cases don't always result in meaningful creditor recoveries. It depends on the debtor's assets and liabilities. Legal fees for petitioning creditors can also erode distributions. But an involuntary filing may give creditors leverage to negotiate a settlement.

‍

Debtor's Defenses and Options

‍

The debtor has several options to defend themselves against an involuntary bankruptcy petition filed by creditors. 

‍

One of the most common defenses is seeking a dismissal of the case. The debtor can argue that the creditors filed the petition in bad faith or did not properly meet the legal requirements. For example, if the creditors filed solely to collect on a debt or did not have the minimum number required. The court may dismiss the case if the petition was improper.

‍

The debtor could also try negotiating a settlement or repayment plan with creditors outside of bankruptcy. This avoids a legal proceeding and may offer better terms than bankruptcy. The debtor needs to act quickly and get creditors to agree to withdraw their petition. This requires convincing creditors that the negotiated deal is preferable.

‍

Finally, the debtor can voluntarily convert the involuntary case into a regular Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 bankruptcy. This allows the debtor to maintain more control. The debtor becomes the "debtor in possession" and can operate their business during reorganization. Voluntary conversion also looks better for the debtor and avoids an adversarial fight over the petition. However, the debtor must still cooperate fully with the bankruptcy process.

‍

The key for debtors is acting fast to protect their interests. By challenging the petition, seeking dismissal, negotiating new terms or voluntarily converting, the debtor can limit the damage of involuntary bankruptcy. Working with legal counsel is essential to navigate the complexities of fighting back against a creditor petition.

‍

Potential Case Outcomes

‍

Involuntary bankruptcy cases can lead to a few different potential outcomes depending on the specific circumstances of the debtor and creditors involved. Some of the most common resolutions include:

‍

Liquidation and Distribution to Creditors

‍

If the debtor's assets and income streams are deemed insufficient to repay debts over time, the court may order a liquidation process. The appointed bankruptcy trustee sells off the debtor's nonexempt assets and uses the proceeds to repay creditors according to bankruptcy law priority. 

‍

Secured creditors are paid first, based on the value of their collateral. Unsecured creditors receive a pro-rata distribution of whatever funds remain. This allows creditors to recover some of what they are owed, even if full repayment is impossible.

‍

Reorganization Plan 

‍

For debtors with income and assets to keep operating, the court may approve a Chapter 11 reorganization plan. This allows the business to restructure debts and emerge from bankruptcy as an ongoing entity.

‍

The reorganization plan must be approved by creditors and provide for the repayment of a meaningful amount of unsecured debts over 3-5 years. This avoids liquidation while giving the debtor a fresh start.

‍

Discharge of Unpaid Debts

‍

Any remaining unpaid debts after the conclusion of the bankruptcy case may be discharged. This releases the debtor from further personal liability, though secured creditors can still repossess collateral.

‍

Discharge provides the debtor with a legal fresh start free from past unsecured debts that couldn't be repaid in the bankruptcy. However, certain debts like taxes and fraud judgments may not be dischargeable.

‍

Alternatives to Involuntary Bankruptcy

‍

Rather than pursuing the complex and often costly process of involuntary bankruptcy, creditors have other options they can consider first. 

‍

Out-of-Court Settlement Negotiations

‍

Creditors can try to negotiate a settlement directly with the debtor outside of court. This may involve agreeing to reduced or partial repayment of the outstanding debts on a payment plan. Settlements avoid legal fees and delays and allow both parties to avoid the risks of involuntary bankruptcy. They require good-faith negotiations and willingness to compromise on both sides.

‍

State Law Debt Collection Remedies 

‍

Under state laws, creditors have certain remedies to collect debts outside of bankruptcy court. These may include garnishing wages, placing liens on property, or seizing certain assets. While less severe than bankruptcy, these options do allow creditors to recover some debts without a full bankruptcy proceeding.

‍

Assigning Debts to Collection Agency

‍

Creditors can assign uncollected debts to a professional debt collection agency or law firm. These agencies have expertise in collecting on delinquent accounts through demand letters, calls, negotiations, and litigation if needed. They work on commission after collecting on the debts. This allows creditors to outsource the collection process.

‍

While involuntary bankruptcy is a last option for creditors, exploring these alternatives first can potentially lead to recovering debts outside of court through settlement or collection actions. The best approach depends on the specific circumstances of the debts and the debtor's financial situation.

‍