12
min read

Involuntary Insolvency: A Creditor's Nuclear Option

Updated on
April 29, 2024

What is Involuntary Insolvency?

Involuntary insolvency, otherwise known as involuntary bankruptcy, is a legal process where creditors can initiate bankruptcy proceedings against a debtor without their consent. This is different from the more common voluntary bankruptcy, where the debtor voluntarily files and consents to the bankruptcy process. 

An involuntary bankruptcy petition can be filed under Chapter 7 or Chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code. In an involuntary Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor's assets are liquidated and distributed to creditors. Under Chapter 11, the debtor usually continues operating and works with creditors on a repayment plan.

The main difference between voluntary and involuntary bankruptcy is that the debtor does not choose to enter bankruptcy in an involuntary case. The bankruptcy proceedings are forced upon the debtor by their creditors. This usually happens when creditors have tried other means of collecting on unpaid debts but have been unsuccessful. Filing for involuntary bankruptcy is typically a creditor's last resort option.

The goal for creditors is to use the bankruptcy process to receive payment on what they are owed from the debtor's assets and future income. Debtors usually want to avoid involuntary bankruptcy because it means loss of control over their finances and business affairs. Key parties involved are the bankruptcy court, trustees, the creditors who filed the involuntary petition, and the debtor.

Understanding the legal requirements for creditors to file an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor is crucial in navigating the complex bankruptcy process.

Legal Requirements to File

In order for creditors to file an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor, there are certain legal requirements that must be met. The eligibility criteria, minimum number of petitioning creditors, and types of claims that can be used to force a debtor into bankruptcy are all important considerations.

Eligibility Criteria

The U.S. Courts Bankruptcy Code sets out eligibility requirements that creditors must satisfy before they can file an involuntary petition:

- Creditors must have claims that are not contingent as to liability or subject to a bona fide dispute. This means the debtor must undisputedly owe the debt.

- If there are 12 or more creditors, at least 3 creditors must join in the involuntary petition.  

- If there are fewer than 12 creditors, 1 creditor can file an involuntary petition on its own.

Minimum Number of Petitioning Creditors

The minimum number of creditors required depends on the total number of creditors the debtor has:

  • 1 petitioning creditor if the debtor has fewer than 12 creditors
  • 3 petitioning creditors if the debtor has 12 or more creditors

All petitioning creditors must meet the eligibility criteria. The number is based on all creditors, not just those willing to join the petition.

Types of Claims 

The claims used for an involuntary filing can be unsecured or secured debt but they must not be contingent. Typical qualifying claims include:

  • Goods or services provided to the debtor 
  • Loans made to the debtor
  • Unpaid employee wages
  • Breach of contract damages

Claims that are disputed by the debtor cannot be used as the basis for an involuntary petition.

Once qualifying claims have been identified, the process of filing an involuntary bankruptcy petition involves a series of steps and requirements that must be followed, ensuring proper documentation and notification procedures are in place.

pen writing on involuntary bankruptcy petition

Filing an Involuntary Bankruptcy Petition

Filing an involuntary bankruptcy petition is a multi-step process that requires specific documentation and procedures for notification. Here is an overview of what is involved:

Step-by-Step Process

To initiate an involuntary bankruptcy case against a debtor or start a forced bankruptcy by the creditor, the petitioning creditors must file the involuntary petition along with supporting documentation with the bankruptcy court in the district where the debtor has resided or maintained a business for the longest portion of the 180 days preceding the filing. 

The process typically involves:

  • Consulting with legal counsel to prepare the petition and verify eligibility. Lawyers can help navigate the documentation requirements.

  • Gathering information and documentation to prove the debtor is generally not paying debts as they come due. This may include unpaid invoices, legal judgments, collection notices, and other evidence of non-payment.

  • Identifying the appropriate bankruptcy court and any applicable filing fees. The proper venue is determined based on the debtor's location.

  • Preparing the involuntary bankruptcy petition (Official Form 105) and gathering the required accompanying documentation. 

  • Filing the completed petition package with the bankruptcy court clerk's office in person or electronically through the court's electronic filing system.

  • Serving notification and copies of the petition on the debtor through approved means as outlined in the bankruptcy rules.

Required Documentation

The creditors filing the involuntary petition must provide documentation showing the debtor meets the requirements for an involuntary case. This includes:

  • A list of all known creditors and their addresses, as well as details on which creditors are joining the petition.

  • Evidence showing the debtor is generally not paying debts, such as unpaid invoices overdue by 90+ days.

  • Proof of the petitioning creditors' claims, such as judgments, promissory notes, or other contracts.

  • A corporate ownership statement if the debtor is a corporation.

  • The completed involuntary bankruptcy petition form.

  • A filing fee payable to the bankruptcy court, unless a fee waiver is obtained.

Notification and Service of Process

Once the petition is filed, the debtor must be properly notified and served:

  • The court provides notification of the filing to the debtor. 

  • Petitioning creditors must arrange formal service of process on the debtor, following rules for the timing, means of delivery, and proof of service.

  • If the debtor cannot be located, creditors may need to request alternate means of service through publication.

Proper notification and service of process is key, as deficiencies can provide grounds for the debtor to contest the involuntary filing.

Ensuring that the debtor is notified and served correctly is essential before delving into the specific eligibility thresholds that debtors must meet for creditors to file an involuntary bankruptcy petition successfully.

Eligibility Thresholds

In order for creditors to successfully file an involuntary bankruptcy petition, the debtor must meet certain eligibility thresholds set forth in the bankruptcy code. The primary requirements relate to the minimum debt owed and number of creditors joining the petition.

Minimum Debt Thresholds

The minimum debt thresholds for bankruptcy differ based on the chapter under which the creditors wish to file. For a Chapter 7 liquidation, the debtor must owe at least $16,750 to the petitioning creditors. To file an involuntary Chapter 11 reorganization, the debtor must owe at least $16,750 to petitioners with at least $16,750 owed to outside creditors. 

For Chapter 7, the petitioning creditors' claims must aggregate at least $16,750 more than any liens securing those claims. For Chapter 11, the aggregate claims of all creditors, not just petitioners, must be at least $16,750 over any liens. The bankruptcy code does not allow creditors to file involuntary Chapter 13 petitions.

Exceptions and Limitations 

Farmers and nonprofit organizations cannot be forced into involuntary bankruptcy. Additionally, involuntary petitions are prohibited against persons receiving income as wages, salary or commissions. There are also exemptions for certain regulated financial institutions.

If an involuntary petition does not satisfy the minimum debt thresholds, the bankruptcy court will dismiss the petition. Consequences for improper filings can include compensatory and punitive damages awarded to the debtor.

The bankruptcy court's pivotal role in evaluating and potentially appointing an interim bankruptcy trustee underscores its exclusive jurisdiction over all bankruptcy matters, including the initial review of involuntary bankruptcy petitions to ensure compliance with legal requirements and thresholds.

insolvency law book in bankruptcy court

Role of the Bankruptcy Court

The bankruptcy court plays a critical role in overseeing involuntary bankruptcy cases. The court has exclusive jurisdiction over all bankruptcy matters, including involuntary filings. 

When an involuntary petition is filed, the bankruptcy court first reviews the petition to ensure it meets the legal requirements and thresholds. If the petition is accepted, the court may appoint an interim bankruptcy trustee to protect the debtor's assets while the case proceeds. 

One of the most significant powers of the bankruptcy court is imposing an automatic stay as soon as the involuntary case is initiated. The automatic stay immediately stops any collection activities against the debtor, including foreclosures, wage garnishments, creditor lawsuits, and more. This provides temporary relief for the debtor while giving the court time to resolve the involuntary bankruptcy case.

If the involuntary bankruptcy moves forward, the court will confirm the appointment of a permanent bankruptcy trustee. The trustee has extensive responsibilities, including liquidating assets, investigating the debtor's finances, challenging improper transfers, and maximizing the value of the bankruptcy estate.

Throughout the process, the bankruptcy court oversees all proceedings and filings. The judge must approve the appointment of professionals, certain asset sales, and plans to reorganize or liquidate the debtor's assets and liabilities. All parties in an involuntary bankruptcy, including creditors and the debtor, have the right to be heard by the judge during the case.

Ultimately, the bankruptcy court has the authority to grant a bankruptcy discharge to the debtor, approve a reorganization plan, convert the case to another bankruptcy chapter, dismiss the involuntary petition, or provide any other appropriate relief. The court serves as the central authority overseeing involuntary bankruptcies from start to finish.

As the central authority overseeing involuntary bankruptcies, the bankruptcy court not only has the power to grant a discharge, approve a reorganization plan, or dismiss the petition but also plays a crucial role in safeguarding the rights and responsibilities of creditors when an involuntary bankruptcy petition is filed against a debtor.

Creditors' Rights and Responsibilities

Creditors have specific rights and responsibilities when an involuntary bankruptcy petition is filed against a debtor. 

Proof of Claim Requirements

All creditors in an involuntary bankruptcy case must file a proof of claim to participate in any distribution from the bankruptcy estate. This is a formal statement filed with the bankruptcy court that states the amount the debtor owes and the reason for the debt. Proof of claims must adhere to strict timelines, with a deadline typically 3-4 months after the bankruptcy filing. Supporting documentation should be included. 

Participation in Creditors' Meetings 

The U.S. Trustee will call at least one meeting of creditors in an involuntary bankruptcy case. Creditors can attend and question the debtor under oath about their finances and operations. Creditors should review the case docket and filings before attending. Telephonic participation may be allowed. Creditors should consult counsel on strategy.

Priority and Distribution of Assets

Creditor claims are prioritized for repayment in bankruptcy. Secured creditors get paid first from the proceeds of liquidated collateral. Unsecured creditors are paid based on a priority scheme set by law. General unsecured creditors are last in line. Involuntary bankruptcy aims to maximize and fairly distribute assets to creditors based on priority.

The prioritization of creditor claims and the goal of maximizing asset distribution based on priority in involuntary bankruptcy directly ties into the significant impact it can have on the debtor's business operations and key stakeholders, particularly in four main areas.

Impact on Debtors and Stakeholders

An involuntary bankruptcy filing can have a major impact on the debtor's business operations and key stakeholders. The four main areas affected are:

Operations

Once an involuntary petition is filed, the debtor loses a significant amount of control over the business. While the company can still operate in the ordinary course, major strategic decisions and transactions are subject to bankruptcy court approval. Business activities are monitored by the interim trustee appointed by the court. The debtor's management may be pressured to implement changes to maximize value for creditors.

Employees  

The company will likely implement cost-cutting measures that impact employees. Hiring freezes, layoffs, and benefit reductions are common. Morale may suffer due to job insecurity. However, employees' wages and benefits are given high priority in bankruptcy, so in some cases the debtor will continue paying employees normally.

Suppliers and Customers

Critical suppliers may tighten credit terms or require cash on delivery, disrupting operations. Customers may lose confidence and take their business elsewhere due to uncertainty. However, the debtor can request court orders to honor customer deposits and critical trade agreements. Ongoing communication helps retain suppliers and customers.

Reorganization or Liquidation

The debtor can contest an involuntary filing and seek to have the case dismissed. However, if the petition is successful, the company will either reorganize and emerge from bankruptcy, or face liquidation if reorganization appears unfeasible. An involuntary case is more likely to result in liquidation compared to a voluntary filing.

Navigating the outcome of an involuntary filing, whether leading to reorganization or liquidation, underscores the importance for creditors to engage in meticulous strategic planning when contemplating initiating an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor.

creditors discussing involuntary bankruptcy strategies

Strategies for Creditors 

When creditors are considering filing an involuntary bankruptcy petition against a debtor, careful strategic planning is essential. Creditors should thoroughly assess the viability and potential benefits of triggering an involuntary case.

Assessing Viability

Before moving forward with an involuntary petition, creditors should realistically evaluate the likelihood of success. Factors to analyze include:

  • The debtor's current financial situation and solvency 
  • Whether the legal requirements for an involuntary filing can be met
  • The potential for the debtor to contest or dismiss the petition
  • Projected costs versus potential recovery for creditors

If the involuntary petition appears likely to fail or recover little for creditors, alternatives may be preferable.

Exploring Alternatives 

In some cases, an out-of-court solution like negotiation or mediation with the debtor may be more advantageous than plunging into litigation. Compromise deals can potentially recover more for creditors without the risks and costs of involuntary bankruptcy.

Secured creditors may have strong leverage to negotiate a settlement based on the collateral backing their claims. Unsecured creditors can also negotiate payment plans, sometimes in collaboration as a group for greater influence. 

Secured vs. Unsecured Creditor Considerations

Secured creditors are often in a better position in involuntary cases, especially if their collateral is essential to the debtor's operations. They can request adequate protection for assets at risk.

Unsecured creditors pursue involuntary bankruptcy to access the debtor's unencumbered assets for distribution. But they face risks like legal costs and potential retaliation if the petition fails. Coordinating with other unsecured creditors can offset these downsides.

In pursuing access to unencumbered assets for distribution, unsecured creditors must navigate potential risks such as legal costs and possible retaliation if the petition fails.

However, effective coordination with other unsecured creditors can serve as a strategic measure to mitigate these downsides. This underlines the critical importance of timeliness when pursuing an involuntary bankruptcy petition, as any delay can significantly jeopardize the chances of a successful case.

Best Practices and Tips

Timeliness is critical when pursuing an involuntary bankruptcy petition. Creditors must act promptly when problems arise and be aware of strict deadlines for filing petitions and responding to motions. Delay can jeopardize the chances of a successful involuntary case.

Work closely with experienced bankruptcy counsel. Involuntary bankruptcy involves complex legal issues and requirements. Having a knowledgeable attorney to provide guidance and handle filings is essential. Do not try to pursue involuntary bankruptcy without competent legal representation.

Have a risk management plan. Be prepared for potential counterclaims or other aggressive actions by the debtor in response to involuntary bankruptcy. Also have contingency plans if the petition is unsuccessful or the debtor contests the case. Managing risks upfront improves outcomes.

Be strategic in using leverage. Involuntary bankruptcy gives creditors leverage over the debtor, but avoid being overly aggressive. Using involuntary bankruptcy as a last resort after other options are exhausted can be more effective.

Document thoroughly. Keep meticulous records of all claims, correspondence with debtor, overdue payments and other information supporting the involuntary petition. Thorough documentation makes it much easier to prove the case.

Coordinate with other creditors. Build consensus with other creditors owed money by the debtor. A united front strengthens the case for involuntary bankruptcy. But don't make improper agreements or collude on strategy.

Consider alternatives first. In some cases, negotiation, mediation or other remedies may resolve issues without needing involuntary bankruptcy. Weigh alternatives before taking the serious step of forcing a debtor into bankruptcy.

Before resorting to the potent tool of involuntary bankruptcy, exploring alternative solutions such as negotiation and mediation is prudent. It's essential to weigh these alternatives carefully before taking the significant step of involuntarily forcing a debtor into bankruptcy.This approach ensures a thorough consideration of all options and their potential to resolve issues without the need for bankruptcy intervention.

Conclusion

Involuntary bankruptcy is a powerful legal approach that creditors can use as a last resort when debtors refuse to pay or file bankruptcy voluntarily. However, the complex legal requirements, costs, and risks mean it should not be pursued lightly. 

The threshold for filing is high, requiring at least three creditors with qualifying claims exceeding a specified debt minimum. Creditors must be strategic in building their case and work closely with legal counsel to navigate court proceedings. While an involuntary filing stops collections and creates pressure for repayment, it could also lead to litigation or liquidation.

Before pursuing involuntary bankruptcy, creditors should thoroughly evaluate alternatives like negotiation, mediation or state law remedies. Seeking a consensual workout agreement is generally preferable to forcing a debtor into bankruptcy. An involuntary petition is not guaranteed to recover debts and could damage relationships.

If every other option is exhausted, creditors must act quickly to meet deadlines and comply with all procedural rules. A misstep could lead to dismissal, leaving the creditors worse off. Close coordination and extensive due diligence are essential. While involuntary bankruptcy can be an effective collections tool, creditors should use it judiciously, with eyes wide open to the risks.

Speak to a Debt Specialist Today

You will always know your settlement amount before you hire us to represent you.