min read

How to Stop a Lawsuit From a Creditor: 7 Proven Tactics to Protect Yourself

Updated on
April 25, 2024

1. Understand Your Rights and Options When Facing a Creditor Lawsuit

Receiving notice that you're being sued by a creditor can be scary and overwhelming. However, it's important not to panic. You have rights and options to respond strategically. Before we talk about the good things of how to stop a lawsuit from a creditor, let's mention the worst thing you can do first.

The worst thing you can do is ignore the lawsuit. This will likely result in a default judgment against you. The creditor will be able to garnish your wages, put liens on your property, and otherwise collect the debt.

Instead, be sure to respond to the summons and complaint by the deadline. This allows you to exercise your right to challenge the validity of the debt through the debt validation process. Ask the creditor to provide complete statements showing you are responsible for the debt and that they have the legal right to collect. 

Consulting a bankruptcy attorney is also advisable. They can assess your financial situation and determine if bankruptcy may be a viable path forward to discharge the debt and halt the creditor's lawsuit. While bankruptcy has consequences for your credit, it may be preferable to a potential execution of judgment.

Overall, be proactive in responding and seeking legal assistance. Carefully review your options, know your rights, and don't let fear cause you to bury your head in the sand. You can fight back against creditor lawsuits.

2. Review the Creditor’s Complaint and Court Documents Thoroughly

When you are served with a creditor lawsuit, your first step should be to carefully review the complaint and all accompanying documents. Do not ignore any notices from the court. Go through each document line-by-line to understand what the creditor is alleging and the timeline involved.

Look for any errors, inconsistencies, or missing information that could potentially invalidate the creditor's claims. Check to confirm your name, address, account numbers, and the debt amount listed are all correct. Scrutinize the documentation that the creditor has provided as evidence of the debt. 

Pay close attention to important dates and deadlines listed in the documents, such as the date you must file your response by. Missing a court deadline could result in an automatic default judgment against you, so be sure to calendar all due dates. You typically have 21 days to submit your official response after being served according to the U.S. Courts, but this can vary based on your state and type of lawsuit.

Thoroughly reviewing the complaint helps you gain clarity on the situation and identify the creditor's assertions and any weak points in their claims. This understanding will allow you to determine the best defense strategies and counterarguments to make in your response. Having precise details about the alleged debt and the creditor's contentions makes it possible to raise specific challenges on legal or factual grounds.

Do not wait to dig into the lawsuit documents. The more time you have to examine the creditor’s position and build your counter case, the better. Being proactive in dissecting the complaint as soon as possible gives you a head start on protecting yourself against the lawsuit.

3. Raise Challenges and Defenses Against the Creditor Lawsuit

One of the most effective ways to fight a creditor lawsuit is to raise challenges and defenses that can call into question the validity of the debt or the creditor's right to pursue legal action. Here are some key strategies to consider:

Dispute Debt Validity or Ownership

Carefully review all documentation the creditor provides as evidence of the debt. Check for errors, inconsistencies, or lack of proof that you actually owe the amount claimed. Force the creditor to validate the debt and prove ownership. If they cannot provide adequate documentation, the court may dismiss the lawsuit.

Assert Expiration of Statute of Limitations

Each state sets legal time limits on how long a creditor can sue to collect a debt. If the statute of limitations has expired, argue that the creditor filed outside the allowable window. Consult your state's laws and have the lawsuit dismissed if the statute of limitations has lapsed.

Counterclaims for FDCPA Violations

If the creditor has violated provisions of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), such as harassment or false statements, consider a counterclaim. Sue the creditor for illegal practices under the FDCPA. This can give you leverage to have the original lawsuit dropped.

Raising substantive challenges and defenses forces the creditor to prove their case. Often, they may not have adequate documentation or may have acted illegally. Fighting back against questionable lawsuits is key to protecting your rights.

4. Explore Debt Settlement or Payment Agreements

blue comparison graphic of debt settlement and payment arrangements

Seeking a settlement or payment agreement with the creditor can help resolve the lawsuit without going to court. There are pros and cons to consider:

Benefits of Settlement

  • Have more control over the outcome. You can negotiate terms rather than leaving it to a judge.

  • Get debt relief. Settling may lower the amount owed or create a payment plan.

  • Stop collections and harassment. The creditor may agree to stop contacting you.

Risks of Settlement

  • Damages credit. Settling is still reported to credit bureaus.

  • Paying anything restarts SOL. The statute of limitations resets if you make a payment.

  • Debt remains valid. Settling doesn't invalidate the underlying debt.

  • Future collection possible. The creditor could sell the debt to another collector.

Payment Plans

Payment plans allow you to pay off the debt over time. Get any agreement for installments in writing with clear terms:

  • Payment amount and frequency 

  • Length of plan and total owed  

  • Effect on lawsuit dismissal 

  • Consequences of missed payments

Having a documented payment schedule can help avoid court but read the fine print. Consult a lawyer before signing anything or have us at Cain and Daniels help settle your debt with no retainer or setup fee.

Get it in Writing

Any negotiated settlement or payment plan must be in writing. Verbal agreements are hard to prove. Make sure any deal includes:

  • Specific settlement terms or payment plan details

  • Agreement to dismiss the lawsuit 

  • No admission of liability on your part

Having a signed agreement protects you and holds the creditor accountable. But think carefully before signing over rights or admitting responsibility.

5. Seek Legal Assistance If Necessary

Facing a lawsuit from a creditor can be an intimidating and stressful experience. While you have the right to represent yourself in court, consulting with a debt specialist like Cain and Daniels may provide invaluable guidance and support on your next steps. However, an attorney experienced in debt collection defense can help level the playing field against creditors and debt buyers if the lawsuit does go to court.

Seeking legal assistance is especially advised if the amount demanded is significant, your livelihood is threatened, or you lack the time, knowledge, or skills for an effective self-defense. An attorney can provide expertise in challenging the validity of debts, navigating court procedures, gathering supporting evidence, and negotiating favorable settlements. They may also uncover violations of consumer protection laws that could lead to the lawsuit being dismissed.  

If you cannot afford a private attorney, explore legal aid resources in your state. Organizations like legal aid societies, law school clinics, and pro bono assistance programs may provide free or low-cost legal services to qualifying individuals. They can help review your case, draft responses, and represent you in settlement conferences or court hearings. With an advocate on your side, you can avoid feeling overwhelmed when contesting a creditor's claims.

6. File Answers and Motions Carefully during Creditor Lawsuit

Once you have been served with a summons and complaint, you must respond within the time period specified, usually 21 days. Failing to respond could result in a default judgment against you. It's critical to follow all court rules, procedures, and deadlines when filing your response.

Your answer to the complaint allows you to admit or deny the allegations and set forth any defenses. Draft your answer clearly and accurately, denying any inaccurate or unsubstantiated claims. Provide as much supporting documentation as you can to refute the creditor's assertions. You may also make counterclaims against the creditor if you believe they have acted unlawfully.

In addition to an answer, you may also file motions to request that the court take certain actions, such as dismissing the case. Motions should lay out compelling legal arguments and case law to support your position. Work closely with legal counsel to develop effective motions that align with your overall legal strategy. 

Submit your filings by the specified deadlines and follow all formatting rules. Keep copies of everything you submit. If you miss a deadline, you may be able to file a motion to seek an extension or reopen the case. But it's always best to calendar deadlines to avoid missing them.

Well-drafted, accurate responses supported by documentation can help demonstrate the merits of your case. Work methodically through each stage of the litigation process. With the right evidence and legal arguments, you may be able to resolve the lawsuit on favorable terms.

7. Prepare Your Case and Evidence

To defend yourself in a creditor lawsuit, you need to gather and organize all relevant documents and information related to the debt and your interactions with the creditor. This preparation is key to refuting the creditor's claims and arguments in court.

Make sure you have easy access to important documents like your credit report from the time the account was opened, the original credit agreement or contract, statements and correspondence with the creditor, records of any payments made, and any communication about the debt being sold or transferred. Highlight important dates, events, conversations, and discrepancies. 

Try to anticipate what evidence and arguments the creditor might present. They may bring up your payment history, interest charges, fees, or other factors to demonstrate you owe the amount they are suing for. Prepare counterpoints by carefully reviewing the documents to identify possible inaccuracies, errors, or violations.

If there are any other records you need to build your case that are held by the creditor or a third party, you can request to subpoena those records through proper legal procedures. This could include payment processing records, commission of oaths, correspondence, or creditor account records that may support your defense.

Thorough preparation and organization will help you mount the strongest defense and be ready to respond to the creditor's claims in court. Focus on gathering irrefutable evidence and information that contradicts or weakens the creditor's arguments.

Bonus: Consider Bankruptcy to Halt the Lawsuit

Filing for bankruptcy may provide a means to stop a creditor lawsuit depending on your specific circumstances. There are two main types of bankruptcy - Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 - that function differently but can both put the brakes on a lawsuit.

Chapter 7 bankruptcy liquidates your assets to pay back creditors. Any remaining dischargeable debts are wiped clean, forcing creditors to stop collection efforts. However, you may have to forfeit certain assets. 

Chapter 13 bankruptcy involves a 3-5 year repayment plan to creditors using future income. It allows you to keep assets like your home but requires continued payments. Creditors are barred from suing over the debts included in the repayment plan.

Consulting a bankruptcy attorney is crucial to decide if filing is the appropriate solution for your situation. The timing of filing bankruptcy can also impact how effectively it halts the lawsuit, as creditors may still obtain judgments if too late. An attorney can provide guidance on how bankruptcy interacts with the legal process.

While bankruptcy may seem like an extreme measure, it can provide permanent protection in some cases from creditor lawsuits and collection activities. Your attorney can objectively evaluate if the benefits outweigh the drawbacks for your unique circumstances. With the right legal strategy, filing for bankruptcy could provide the shield you need to gain control of your finances from creditor lawsuits.

Added Tip: Understand Post-Judgment Debt Collection

If the creditor is awarded a judgment against you, they gain significant power to collect on the debt through legal means. This may involve aggressive tactics like wage garnishment, bank account levies, or property liens. 

Wage Garnishment

If allowed in your state, the creditor can obtain a court order to have a portion of your paycheck withheld by your employer to pay off the debt. Federal law sets limits on how much can be garnished - usually 25% of your disposable earnings or the amount above 30 times the minimum wage.

You may be able to claim exemptions from wage garnishment if it would cause extreme financial hardship. File the proper paperwork with the court to claim a hardship exemption.

Bank Levies 

The creditor can seize funds from your bank accounts through a bank levy ordered by the court. Federal law protects limited funds like Social Security, disability payments, and child support, but most of your money can be taken.

Avoid depositing any assets or money gifts into your accounts. Open a separate exempt account and have your protected income like Social Security deposited there.

Property Liens

A judgment lien can be placed on your real estate or personal property, allowing it to potentially be seized and sold to pay off the debt. Pay attention to any notices of liens and act promptly to avoid losing property.

You may be able to claim exemptions on certain property like a primary residence. Consult with a legal aid lawyer to understand how to protect your assets.

Overall, act quickly if you receive a judgment against you and be prepared for the creditor to aggressively pursue repayment. Seek legal help to shield your wages, bank accounts, and property.

Don't Let It Happen Again - Improve Financial Health

Getting hit with a lawsuit can be a wake-up call about the need to get your finances in order or seek insight from debt advisors. Use it as motivation to start fresh and rebuild your financial health.

Create a budget and stick to it. Track your income and expenses, look for ways to cut spending, and allocate funds to pay off debts. A budget helps you gain control over your finances.

Contact creditors before debts become delinquent. Staying current on payments keeps accounts in good standing. If you anticipate struggles with a payment, call the creditor right away to discuss options.

Pay down balances and consolidate debt. Focus on paying down high-interest debts while making minimums on others. Consider debt consolidation loans or balance transfer cards to simplify payments. 

Rebuild your credit. Check reports for errors and start establishing positive payment histories. Consider secured cards if you can't qualify for traditional credit yet.

Boost your savings. Aim to build 3-6 months' worth of living expenses in emergency savings. This cushions you from unexpected expenses that could derail your finances.

Seek credit counseling help. Non-profit credit counseling provides budgeting assistance, debt management plans, and ongoing education to help people regain financial control.

Negotiate with creditors. If you still struggle with debt payments, contact creditors to negotiate modified payment plans, reduced interest rates, debt settlements, or other options. 

Create financial goals. Define short and long-term money goals to stay motivated. This also helps ensure you align spending with what matters most to you.

With diligence and commitment to better financial practices, you can avoid repeating past mistakes. A creditor lawsuit does provide a pivotal chance to rehabilitate your finances and credit.

Speak to a Debt Specialist Today

You will always know your settlement amount before you hire us to represent you.